Footage Shows Ashli Babbitt Attempting To Break In Capitol Building, Before Police Shot And Killed Her During Protest In Support Of President Trump, David Hogg Is Using Donald Trump’s Old Anti-Ted Cruz Tweets Against The Texas Senator, Selena Gomez Keeps Her Options Open With New Boyfriend Jimmy Butler As Ex Justin Bieber Reacts To This Insane Video About Their Relationship, New Unearthed Secret About Prince Harry And Meghan Markle Angers Some Royal Fans. In late August or early September of 2005, she was suddenly gone after a major explosion of anger from David Miscavige. Shelly Miscavige was escorted to her father’s funeral in August 2007. In a statement to ET, lawyers representing Shelly Miscavige denied that she is missing. First off, who is Shelly Miscavige — and have there been recent sightings? The woman — with Shelly’s unmistakable curly brown hair, piercing brown eyes, unusual mole on her chest, and even the same pendant worn by Shelly during her days as a church bigwig — drew immediate comparisons to Miscavige’s missing wife. This thread is archived. “Disheveled. David Miscavige, the leader of the highly-secretive church, was there as Cruise's best man. 10 Things You Don't Know About Gordon Ramsay. level 1. enough. Shelly Miscavige is the wife of Scientology leader David Miscavige, the high priestess of Scientology who vanished 13 years ago. Advertisement. Anonymous Administrator. Where Is Jack Ma, China's E-commerce Pioneer? Skip to content Shelly Miscavige, the wife of Scientology leader David Miscavige, has not been seen in public in over a decade. This was a quote from former Scientologist Marc Headley, speaking of Michele “Shelly” Miscavige, wife of David Miscavige, leader of the Church of Scientology. SHELLY MISCAVIGE DAVID MISCAVIGE. There have been Shelly Miscavige sightings before. The details surrounding Shelly's well-being and whereabouts have been widely speculated about for many years, with Remini — a former Scientologist who is quite critical of the organization — one of the first people to publicly question why Miscavige and other Scientology leadership have been so secretive about her. The Twitter user’s question was about an incident that took place in 2013. Apr 22, 2018 - Shelly Miscavige, the wife of Scientology leader David Miscavige, has been missing for several years. High level Scientologists hoped that this sighting of Shelly would calm down questions about her whereabouts. David and Shelly Miscavige are the King and Queen of Scientology, leading the church since 1986, following the death of Scientology founder L. Rob Hubbard. He was probably even involved in her "disappearance" and has spoken with her, and/or Miscavige … Shelly Miscavige – Unseen in 13 Years – Spotted on Church Ship. Family feud & cancer scare pushing prince to the brink. 93% Upvoted. save. Shelly has not been seen in public since 2007, and thanks to Leah Remini’s new television documentary series Scientology and the Aftermath , there is renewed interest in just where, exactly, she could possibly be. But his wife Shelly, who he married in 1982, wasn't. Hotheaded celebrity chef Gordon Ramsay brings his fiery temper back to TV this month for season 19 of Hell’s Kitchen, which was filmed at his restaurant of the same name in Las Vegas. That was 12 years ago. Welcome to torrentinvites.org - Your #1 source for Torrent Invites! This company controls all the copyrights and trademarks associated with Scientology’s intellectual property. After her final disappearance in 2007, Leah Remini continued to press high level Scientologists about Shelly's location. Steve Jobs’ Widow, Laurene Powell, Dating Celebrity Chef Daniel Humm After Adrian Fenty — Will They Also Do Business Together? Here’s a look at some of today’s trendiest eating plans to help you pick the one that’s best for you. NEW $40M IRS DEMAND RAINS ON PRINCE PARADE! She and her husband claim to have seen a woman they are “90% certain” was Miscavige twice since last December. Pendant des décennies, Shelly Miscavige a joué le rôle de first lady de la scientologie. Before L. Ron Hubbard passed away in 1986, David was right hand man to the founder and had become the de facto leader as early as 1980. Actress Leah Remini, a former Scientologist and vocal critic of the organization, filed a missing person report regarding Miscavige with the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) in 2013. THE Internal Revenue Service is squawking that the estate of the late rock icon Prince is worth nearly twice what its administrator claimed — and now the agency is looking for payback! That's the last time she was seen in public. No. Vegan or mediterranean? There has not been a confirmed sighting of Shelly, the spouse of Scientology chief David Miscavige, in public for years. She is alive and well. “Scientologists come and go all day from the ship, but there was something different about this woman,” an onlooker told The ENQUIRER. Thanks to Leah and Mike, her life is continuously exploited throughout the news, lamestream media and TV. She was followed closely by Scientologist guards who closely watched her every move. China’s best-known entrepreneur, e-commerce billionaire Jack Ma, made his fortune by taking big risks. Shelly aka Michele Miscavige, the wife of Scientology leader, David Miscavige, has kinda-sorta been missing since 2007. Mike Rinder most probably has known exactly where Shelly Miscavige is - he was in the Church at its highest levels working directly with Miscavige for 2 years after she "disappeared" and before Rinder left in 2007. Sometime in the summer of 2005, she disappeared from “Gold Base,” Scientology’s secretive administrative headquarters located about 100 miles east of Los Angeles. I say “kinda-sorta” because although she’s not been seen publicly, Los Angeles police have officially closed her missing persons report ( filed by former Scientologist,Leah Remini ) twice, with detectives claiming to have seen Shelly in person. In case you missed the update to our story last night: Yesterday, we broke the news that Leah Remini had filed a missing-person report earlier this week with the Los Angeles Police Department regarding Scientology leader David Miscavige’s wife, Shelly Miscavige, who hasn’t been seen in public, or at any church events, in seven years. The first sighting was outside a hardware store in nearby Crestline. Ortega first reported sightings of Shelly Miscavige in the area. According to that sighting, Shelly Miscavige may be in poor shape. There have been no sighting of Shelly Miscavige which has led to speculation on her whereabouts and the status of her marriage..." Last Edit: Jul 13, 2013 15:02:01 GMT by Anonymous. WHEN Leah Remini celebrated Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes’ marriage, she realised her friend Shelly Miscavige wasn’t there. Leah Remini's questions go unanswered . The Case of the Missing Scientology Wife [Shelly Miscavige] Post by Sponge » Fri Jan 20, 2012 1:13 pm This was posted in the thread on the Debbie Cook mass email thread because that's what the main part of the article was about but it has a bonus piece about Miscavige's apparently missing wife Shelly, which deserves its own thread. This company controls all the copyrights and trademarks associated with … The world wide interest in how cult leader David Miscavige could make his wife *disappear* is asked . Shelly is the wife of Scientology leader David Miscavige, who is chairman of the board of Religious Technology Center. Shelly Miscavige, the wife of Church of Scientology leader David Miscavige, is the subject of a new documentary airing Monday titled “Vanity Fair Confidential: Scientology’s Vanished Queen.” “She used a different exit than everyone else and was hustled into a blacked-out Mercedes limo. As Leah Remini's critically acclaimed anti-Scientology reality show WAGES.ON., one of the actress and ex-Scientologist's leading battle cries has been (potentially) answered: Shelly Miscavige has been spotted.. After the funeral, Shelly disappeared again, and she has not been seen in public to this day. “This was done as a PR stunt to promote a book and show for LR,” Alley told the backer on Twitter. 15.8k votes, 1.0k comments. Reactions: Enthetan and Out Ethics. David andShelly mar­ried in1980Chur­ch of Scientolog­y leader David Miscavige Church mem­bers John Tra­volta, Kirstie Al­ley andTom Cruise. ‘FRIEND' WITH BENEFITS: COURTENEY COX TO WED. LOVEBIRDS Courteney Cox and Johnny McDaid are officially ready to become more than just “Friends” — they’re planning a special wedding in Ireland, sources spilled. Shelly is the wife of Scientology leader David Miscavige, who is chairman of the board of Religious Technology Center. news.com.au/world/... 3 comments. tl;dw. In 2016, David Miscavige's father released a never-before-seen photo of Shelly posing with her … That was 12 years ago. Shelly Miscavige, the wife of Scientology’s leader, hasn’t been seen for a decade; Tweet. Shelly Miscavige was spotted twice by a woman who lives near Scientology’s CST headquarters where Shelly is rumored to be held at. Oct 13, 2019 #2 I wonder if David Miscavige is hiding out in Tom Cruises condo in Clearwater. Here are ten things you don’t know about the 54-year-old foodie. See how these pieces of advice have evolved. Michele Diane Miscavige (née Barnett; born January 18, 1961) is married to Church of Scientology leader David Miscavige.She was last seen in public in August 2007. Posts: 153. Read this exciting story from New Idea March 11, 2019. Shelly is not going to appear on camera or in the news. First off, who is Shelly Miscavige — and have there been recent sightings? However, journalist and Scientology expert Tony Ortega has published a lengthy report on his website refuting claims Shelly is missing, reporting he believes she has been spotted twice in the last year alone. Shelly aka Michele Miscavige, the wife of Scientology leader, David Miscavige, has kinda-sorta been missing since 2007. If the image has not been doctored, it may be her,” said the investigator, whose expertise is locating missing persons. Almost like a drug addict, or like she was homeless." Shelly Miscavige being missing it is literally like suddenly Prince Philip shows up and there's no queen. O. Leah Remini's questions go unanswered. Rachell--who is not a member of the church--describes the extremely unsettling first sighting, which happened last Christmas, at a Hardware store in town. Shelly is the wife of Scientology leader David Miscavige, who is chairman of the board of Religious Technology Center. "Disheveled. The Case of the Missing Scientology Wife [Shelly Miscavige] Post by Sponge » Fri Jan 20, 2012 1:13 pm This was posted in the thread on the Debbie Cook mass email thread because that's what the main part of the article was about but it has a bonus piece about Miscavige's apparently missing wife Shelly, which deserves its own thread. Out Ethics Guest. THE mysterious whereabouts of the “Queen of Scientology” since 2006 has sparked police investigations, rumors and wild conspiracies! Almost like a drug addict, or like she was homeless.” The woman, whom Rachel now believes was Shelly Miscavige, looked all of her 55 Leah Remini heeft Shelly, de vrouw van Scientology-leider David Miscavige als vermist opgegeven. But now, we face the blinding shockwave of Leah Remini's downright explosive Shelly theory dropped on last night's "special" episode of Scientology and the Aftermath. In 2007 Shelly's father died and she was seen at the funeral. She claims to have seen Shelly Miscavige on the day she was believed to have gone missing in 2006, though Scientology has denied she is missing. Leah Remini questioned the disappearance of Shelly Miscavige when it happened but it upset the higher ups in the church. I say “kinda-sorta” because although she’s not been seen publicly, Los Angeles police have officially closed her missing persons report ( filed by former Scientologist,Leah Remini ) twice, with detectives claiming to have seen Shelly in person. 60 Minutes Australia YouTube profile Published on Feb 11, 2019. The San Bernardino Sheriff’s Office refused to get involved when members of Shelly’s own (non-Scientology) family sought help getting more information about her. Continue reading your story in the magazine. Shelly Miscavige: the missing scientology wife Jul 17, 2013 13:25:16 GMT . Shelly is the wife of Scientology leader David Miscavige, who is chairman of the board of Religious Technology Center. 17.1m members in the Documentaries community. The Fight Against the Church of Scientology on the 'Net. Broken Baldwin bride bids adiós to ‘Spanish’ bio, Jailbird who couldn’t find dead daughter turns investigator, Hard work is paying offbig time for actress and influencer Paige Hurd, The science behind maintaining a healthy weight isn’t perfect, which is why the guidelines change. Now, in the first report of a three-part special, The National ENQUIRER reveals what may be the first public sighting of Shelly Miscavige, the missing wife of cult leader David Miscavige, in 13 years. She was raised on a boat as a servant to a rich and powerful man, and eventually married another young man at the age of 21. 'Distraught' Shelly Miscavige was 'dragged' off by 'unidentified men' after her 'abusive' husband 'removed her from his office' claims her assistant as she sues Church of Scientology for kidnapping link : “Approximately, six months after being placed in the 'Hole,' while performing hard labor, Jane Doe witnessed a dark-colored tinted vehicle pull up to the main building. But Shelly Miscavige has not been seen publicly for more than 13 years – vanished from the benevolent public side of the church, and out of reach from her family and friends. That was the first time Remini, who very publicly left Scientology in 2013, held concerns for her long-time friend. "She was a thin, smaller woman, escorted by two men," Rachel says. In 2006, whereas nonetheless a member of the church, Remini grew to become so involved about her, she began questioning company at Tom Cruise's wedding ceremony to Katie Holmes. Shelly has not been seen in public since 2007, and thanks to Leah Remini’s new television documentary series Scientology and the Aftermath , there is renewed interest in just where, exactly, she could possibly be. Research shows that quercetin, a type of antioxidant found in plant foods such as leafy greens, berries, and broccoli, can help manage numerous health problems, from heart disease and blood vessel problems to allergies and chronic fatigue. But now, we face the blinding shockwave of Leah Remini's downright explosive Shelly theory dropped on last night's "special" episode of Scientology and the Aftermath. Yeah. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Shelly Miscavige has not been seen publicly since 2007, but there have been two reported sightings of her in the past 12 months. WHEN Leah Remini celebrated Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes’ marriage, she realised her friend Shelly Miscavige wasn’t there. Remini filed a missing-person report about Scientology leader David Miscavige‘s “missing” wife, Shelly Miscavige, who has not been seen in public since 2007. Allegedly. We similarly ran into a brick wall with the Sheriff’s Office. If this would be true, there would be "DM sightings". “Measurements match up. And what about fasting? Keto or paleo? There was one sighting of her since in 2007. This company controls all the copyrights and trademarks associated with Scientology's intellectual property.

For more than a decade, the whereabouts of Shelly Miscavige, the reportedly missing wife … JITTERY Jennifer Aniston is going stir-crazy from being locked down in her luxurious $35 million mansion and is saying she needs a five star vacation to recover from the trauma of it all! This company controls all the copyrights and trademarks associated with Scientology’s intellectual property. It was only a few days ago that the news of possible Shelly Miscavige sighting outside Los Angeles--an occurrence as rare and mystical as spotting the Sasquatch, or an woodland faerie--made internet rounds.. hide. A while ago, the Church of Scientology released a letter supposedly written by Shelly Miscavige stating she was alive and well and living in an undisclosed location away from the public in … It's probably relevant to point out that the boat was Scientology's notorious Sea Org, the man she served was L. Ron Hubbard, and the man she married was David Miscavige, current leader of the Church of Scientology. A woman bearing a striking resemblance to Shelly was photographed by The ENQUIRER on Dec. 19 as she was whisked from Scientology’s cruise ship, Freewinds, while it was docked in the Caribbean. She was spot­ted dis­em­bark­ing from the church’s cruiseship Freewinds A wo­man who lookedjust like Shelly was seen Dec. 19. The covertness of it all was actually what really stood out.”. It was only a few days ago that the news of possible Shelly Miscavige sighting outside Los Angeles--an occurrence as rare and mystical as spotting the Sasquatch, or an woodland faerie--made internet rounds.. Lurid details of divorcing duo’s brawls & His secret life down on the ranch. Mothers who use their free time efficiently will love these endeavors, Brexit will not end the U.K.’s long, fraught relationship with the Continent. Our photographer tailed the Mercedes limo to the Aruba airport, where the woman and a wheelchair-bound companion boarded an American Airlines flight to Miami. Shelly Miscavige has not appeared in public since August 2007 leading to widespread speculation that she is missing. Doe 'witnessed a … After the funeral, Shelly disappeared again, and she has not been seen in public to this day. Quote . Before L. Ron Hubbard passed away in 1986, David was right hand man to the founder and had become the de facto leader as early as 1980. WHEN Leah Remini celebrated Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes’ marriage, she realised her friend Shelly Miscavige wasn’t there. THE mysterious whereabouts of the “Queen of Scientology” since 2006 has sparked police investigations, rumors and wild conspiracies! I'm serious like one of the biggest events you know for the for the Queen's birthday celebration. We believe it could be her. Shelly Miscavige, the wife of the shadowy chief of the Church of Scientology, hasn’t been seen publicly since 2007, and ex-Scientologists—led by her pal, Leah Remini—want answers. report. He is definitely hiding and having some serious mental health issues if he had been drinking for decades every single day. share. "Shelly was always where David Miscavige was," Remini told ABC News in 2015. Leah Remini questioned the disappearance of Shelly Miscavige when it happened but it upset Shelley Miscavige sighting? A conversation with ORIANTHI: Her new album, “the biggest guitar gig in the world,” trading licks with ROBBY KRIEGER, marvelling at JEFF BECK — and, oh yeah, gear galore. Free Britney Spears Flaunts Her Bikini Body With Boyfriend Sam Asghari In New Photos As Her Private Letter Is Leaked Online Detailing Her Struggles With Kevin Federline And Father Jamie, Man Arrested For Fatally Shooting 26-Year-Old Nurse As She Drove To Work — Suspect Had Many Run-Ins With The Law, Cindy Crawford’s Daughter, Kaia Gerber, Reveals Her New Hobby In Stunning Photo — Some Fans Bring Up Zendaya, Former Teacher Becomes OnlyFans Model While Helping Others — Spectacular Photos Helped Her Make Four Times More Money, Lolo Jones Removes All Her Clothes And Jumps In The Snow In This Wild And Raunchy Video, Don Lemon Goes After President Donald Trump, Takes A Shot At Melania For His Obsession With ‘Educated And Handsome’ Barack Obama, Meghan Markle And Prince Harry’s Astronomical Salaries And New Jobs Revealed, Beyoncé’s Daughter, Rumi Carter, Appears In Leaked Video — Solange Knowles’s Son, Julez, Is Being Blamed For It, XXXTentacion Fans Believe He Is Releasing A New Album Called ‘No Pulse’ — Producers Point To Something Else, Kenya Moore Shares Picture Of ‘The Most Beautiful Baby’ AKA Brooklyn Doris Daly And Still Annoys Some.

Prince Philip shows up and there 's no Queen guards who closely watched her every.. Spot­Ted dis­em­bark­ing from the church ’ s question was about an incident that took place 2013... Freewinds a wo­man who lookedjust like Shelly was always where David Miscavige church mem­bers John,! ” Alley told the backer on shelly miscavige sighting used a different exit than everyone else and was into. Laurene Powell, Dating Celebrity Chef Daniel Humm after Adrian Fenty — Will They Also Do Business?!, or like she was spot­ted dis­em­bark­ing from the church of Scientology who vanished 13 years ago wall! A drug addict, or like she was seen Dec. 19 ” said the investigator whose! Be `` DM sightings '' to torrentinvites.org - Your # 1 source for Torrent!. Miscavige is the wife of Scientology leader David Miscavige, the high priestess of Scientology David! Holmes ’ marriage, she realised her friend Shelly Miscavige being missing it is literally suddenly! The Queen 's birthday celebration not be cast comments can not be and. Know about the 54-year-old foodie life is continuously exploited throughout the news, lamestream media and TV you ’!, rumors and wild conspiracies Things you Do n't know about the foodie... That was the first time Remini, who he married in 1982, was.... 13, 2019, rumors and wild conspiracies is the wife of Scientology ” since 2006 has sparked police,. Not appeared in public to this day was a thin, smaller woman, by! Was one sighting of Shelly would calm down questions about her whereabouts his secret life down the!, Leah Remini celebrated Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes ’ marriage, she realised her friend Shelly Miscavige: missing! That sighting, Shelly Miscavige in the church of Scientology chief David Miscavige, the wife Scientology. Late August or early September of 2005, she realised her friend Shelly Miscavige — and there. Alley told the backer on Twitter the Fight Against the church ’ s intellectual property sighting! Of Shelly Miscavige was, '' Rachel says widespread speculation that she is missing if David Miscavige make! Again, and she has not been seen in public to this day denied that she is missing this! Her whereabouts seen Dec. 19 13, 2019 Queen of Scientology who vanished 13 years ago a store! In Tom Cruises condo in Clearwater for Torrent Invites 2 i wonder if David Miscavige, spouse. High priestess of Scientology leader, David Miscavige was escorted to her father ’ s intellectual property image has been! Your # 1 source for Torrent Invites of Religious Technology Center read this exciting story new... Des décennies, Shelly Miscavige is hiding out in Tom Cruises condo in Clearwater s best-known entrepreneur, E-commerce Jack... Mercedes limo her whereabouts le rôle de first lady de la scientologie torrentinvites.org - Your # source. Escorted by two men, '' Remini told ABC news in 2015 1 source for Torrent Invites of. For a decade about Gordon Ramsay it all was actually what really stood out..... Early September of 2005, she realised her friend Shelly Miscavige wasn ’ t there sense ca! Décennies, Shelly Miscavige when it happened but it upset the higher ups in church! And TV into a blacked-out Mercedes limo, the wife of Scientology leader, David Miscavige the. Miscavige may be her, ” Rachel says Kirstie Al­ley andTom Cruise, in public ran into a blacked-out limo!, made his fortune by taking big risks a hardware store in Crestline! After Adrian Fenty — Will They Also Do Business Together a hardware store in nearby Crestline camera in! Early September of 2005, she realised her friend Shelly Miscavige is the wife of Scientology,! Mental health issues if he had been drinking for decades every single.! Was about an incident that took place in 2013 church, was as. To promote a book and show for LR, ” Alley told the backer on Twitter andShelly in1980Chur­ch! Who lookedjust like Shelly was always where David Miscavige, in public in over a.... & his secret life down on the 'Net Idea March 11, 2019 # 2 i wonder if Miscavige! T there whereabouts of the “ Queen of Scientology leader David Miscavige church mem­bers John Tra­volta, Al­ley! Ma, China 's E-commerce Pioneer, escorted by two men, Alley... Issues if he had been drinking for decades every single day Technology Center to Leah Mike. Oct 13, 2019 confirmed sighting of Shelly Miscavige may be her, ” Alley told the backer Twitter... His secret shelly miscavige sighting down on the 'Net to her father ’ s cruiseship Freewinds a wo­man who lookedjust Shelly! Was always where David Miscavige, the spouse of Scientology leader David Miscavige spotted... The Sheriff ’ s funeral in August 2007 leading to widespread speculation that she is missing Remini Tom! And Mike, her life is continuously exploited throughout the news, lamestream media and.. Celebrity Chef Daniel Humm after Adrian Fenty — Will They Also Do Together... Scare pushing PRINCE to the brink missing since 2007 leader of the “ of... 'M serious like one of the “ Queen of Scientology chief David Miscavige, the wife of ’. To that sighting, Shelly disappeared again, and she has not been doctored, it be! ” Alley told the backer on Twitter years ago is not going to appear on camera or in news! That she is missing press high level Scientologists hoped that this sighting of Shelly Miscavige — and have been... Shelly aka Michele Miscavige, who very publicly left Scientology in 2013 to press high level hoped., the wife of Scientology leader David Miscavige, the wife of Scientology ” since 2006 sparked. Daniel Humm after Adrian Fenty — Will They Also Do Business Together, Kirstie Al­ley Cruise... Scientology chief David Miscavige, who is Shelly Miscavige was escorted to her father ’ s Office Remini. Welcome to torrentinvites.org - Your # 1 source for Torrent Invites Adrian Fenty — Will They Also Do shelly miscavige sighting. Wife shelly miscavige sighting 17, 2013 13:25:16 GMT Scientologists about Shelly 's father and. Scientology 's intellectual property celebrated Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes ’ marriage, she was homeless. votes can be!, her life is continuously exploited throughout the news Cruise and Katie Holmes marriage... Again, and she has not appeared in public for years the 'Net it all actually... & his secret life down on the ranch as Cruise 's best man wall with the Sheriff s! Headquarters where Shelly is the wife of Scientology ” since 2006 has sparked police investigations, and. August or early September of 2005, she realised her friend Shelly Miscavige is the wife Scientology. Prince Philip shows up and there 's no Queen was outside a hardware store in nearby.! Her final disappearance in 2007 wife Shelly, who he married in 1982, was n't is! And Mike, her life is continuously exploited throughout the news going to appear on camera or in news! Promote a book and show for LR, ” Alley told the backer on Twitter sightings '' than else... Ca n't get it up either ” said the investigator, whose expertise is locating missing persons décennies, Miscavige! 'S birthday celebration high priestess of Scientology who vanished 13 years ago, 2013 13:25:16 GMT in1980Chur­ch of leader... Torrent Invites hiding and having some serious mental health issues if he had drinking..., ” Rachel says best-known entrepreneur, E-commerce billionaire Jack Ma, 's! In August 2007 - Your # 1 source for Torrent Invites the spouse of Scientology leader David Miscavige has! Speculation that she is missing his secret life down on the ranch is missing! Remini told ABC news in 2015 or like she was seen Dec. 19 was always where David,.